This post is aimed at: Anyone with social media accounts, particularly people who use them a lot and people who don't use them at all

TLDR: Let's all encourage people with valuable things to say to share them more by a) reducing our own noise and b) taking the oxygen away from the noisy minority who dominate social by just unfollowing them

A client said something interesting in a marketing session this week, which I couldn’t agree more with:

“The problem with social media is it’s full of idiots with huge audiences spouting shite.”

Someone who shall remain nameless (but has quite a large audience!), 2022

This was in the context of trying to help people with a story or a mission to do some good reach a wider audience, and our conversation was around how to do that when the channels seem saturated. His frustration, which I entirely share, is that we seem as a society to be listening to the people who shout the loudest, which is stopping us hearing from people with something worthwhile to say.

Whilst I don’t think this is either entirely limited to, or entirely attributable to, social media (the breakdown of attention spans is a much bigger, really interesting topic with some huge implications for marketing) in this context it’s social media that’s important, because it’s where most people’s attention is at the moment, rightly or wrongly, so for people who have a message to share that’s where the broadest audience is.

We all know there is too much noise on social

Now, it’s not new to suggest that there is too much noise on social media – people have been saying that for over a decade (incidentally I really identify with a quote from that article: “Marketers suck. Including me.“) But the question that most people seem in response to that noise is “how can I cut through it?” (just google “tips for standing out from the social media noise”), and surely in that case you’re just becoming part of the problem. We are ALL convinced that what we have to say is more important, that it’s the signal rather than the noise, but…is it really? No, come on…really?

I like to use ‘in the pub’ analogies with my clients, and it’s particularly apt here. We’re in a situation where we’re in a pub filled with people loudly proclaiming their own thoughts and opinions, veering from completely fucking inane (“hey, look, I’ve got a dog, look at my dog, my dog is wearing a hat, hey, hey, look at me, now look at my dog again, now me”) through misinformed and misguided (but let’s not disappear down the Brexit sewerhole) to actively offensive, all with a meaty side of dull as dishwater. In this terrible pub, there are lots of people who may want to discuss something important to them – but faced with the deluge of nonsense they stay quiet and eventually leave.

This terrible metaphor is actually a real problem – lots of people are deciding to remove themselves from social platforms, and anecdotally it seems to me that they are often the people you would want to hear from. It seems to me that as more moderate, thoughtful people make a moderate, thoughtful decision to spend their time and attention somewhere less awful, the social platforms become…well, less moderate, less thoughtful, more awful.

But what can we do about it?

To be clear, I’m very much in favour of everyone being able to post (and say) what they want, when they want. I just don’t want to have to read it, and I don’t see why it should have equal weight with the opinions of someone who actually knows what they are talking about.

Obviously it would be lovely if social media platforms figured out some way of doing this. Maybe some sort of test that you have to pass before you can post? (That’s not entirely a joke!) But given that it is far from clear about whether these companies can, or even should, moderate even potentially harmful content, there is no chance whatsoever of them telling some their most active users to, without putting too fine a point on it, shut the fuck up.

6 things I’m going to try

I’m fully aware that my opinions in no way matter to this, but it still felt like it was worth saying, and here are a few things that I’m going to do to see if it helps. If you feel like joining me that would be great.

  1. Before I post, and I mean EVERY TIME, I’m going to ask myself three questions: “who is this for, what will they gain from it, and would it hurt them if I didn’t post it?” If in doubt, I’ll err on the side of keeping quiet.
  2. Start identifying who I’m posting for. This ties in with some things I’m thinking about for my PhD, and it just makes sense really – not everything is for everyone, and we could easily make what we are posting and writing more targeted to audiences who will actually find it useful.
  3. Alongside that, I’m going to join the TLDR gang. You might have seen this on articles, and like me you might have thought it was an irritating affectation. But… I was wrong, and you probably are too. Here’s why it’s useful, and if we tied this in with identifying audiences it could really reduce the noise.
  4. Revisit my overall approach to digital presence. I’ve been working through an Open University Course called ‘the digital scholar‘ which is a bit dated but has some really interesting thoughts on how to be more open and interconnected when sharing ideas. It’s something I need to be better at, and I’m looking at Tom Critchlow as an example of how it’s done really well – interesting, curated, thoughtful, interlinked online content but without an overbearing social presence
  5. Actively look for people who I know have worthwhile opinions on a topic and encourage them to share them, whether that’s on social, through blogging, podcasts, whatever. There are lots of people who don’t contribute because they think they haven’t got anything valuable to say, and I haven’t been proactive encouraging them to speak up.
  6. Cull the noisy minority. Not a literal culling, most of them aren’t that bad… But maybe if every time someone posted something banal, pointless or stupid they lost a chunk of their connections or followers that might make them start to consider their posts more carefully. We can dream, anyway! If nothing else, over time this will mean that I personally have to wade through less mindless drivel, so it’s a win regardless.

It’s not much of a manifesto, but until I think of something better these might help me feel that I’m doing my bit.

Similar Posts